Toy Storage Baskets: What to Look For Before You Buy

Storage baskets can make a toy shelf look organized without actually solving clutter, especially if you buy them before sorting what you own. Once you know what needs a home, the material and size choice gets easier.

Common basket materials

• Woven natural fiber (seagrass, water hyacinth, jute): sturdy for light-to-medium toys, adds visual warmth, but not always washable.
• Canvas or cotton bins: soft-sided, easy to fold flat when not in use, machine washable in many cases.
• Wood crates: durable and stackable, but heavier and less forgiving if a toddler climbs on them.

Sizing for actual use

Match basket size to what’s going inside, not just what looks good on a shelf. Small bins work for blocks or figures; larger, open bins work better for stuffed animals or bulkier toys. Oversized single bins tend to become a dumping ground where nothing is easy to find.

Labels help more than lids

For toddlers old enough to help clean up, an open bin with a picture or word label is usually more effective than a bin with a lid, since it removes a step between “toy” and “put away.”

Storage placement

Low, open shelving with baskets at a child’s height supports independent cleanup. Higher shelves work well for rotation storage that’s meant to stay out of daily reach until it’s swapped in.

What to skip

Skip a large matching storage system before you’ve sorted your toys — buying storage first often means guessing at sizes that don’t match what you actually own. Sort, then buy what fits the categories you land on.

Helpful search link

A woven basket in a size that matches one toy category — blocks, or figures, or stuffed animals — is a better starting point than one large catch-all bin.

#1. Woven Toy Storage Basket

$15–$35

Pros

• Sturdy weave holds shape for light-to-medium toys
• Adds visual warmth compared to plastic bins

Cons

• Not machine washable — check care instructions before buying

Check price on Amazon

If you’re setting up a full rotation system rather than just storage, our toy rotation system for small spaces guide covers the swapping side of it.

Bottom line

Pick basket material based on what’s going inside and whether it needs to be washable. Size baskets to specific toy categories rather than one oversized catch-all, and place them at a height that matches how independently your child can help with cleanup.